Photo from
Straws collected on Bondi Beach in Australia. |
I went along on one occasion and while she was discussing
her purchase with a clerk, I chanced to open a door that led to the factory
floor where the straws were being produced. Actually factory floor is kind of a
misnomer because what I saw was a room which memory now tells me was not very
big. Machinery filled almost every
available square inch of floor space except for narrow passageways the operator
used to access the apparatus. A fairly loud mechanical hum added to the feeling of congestion in the room
along with the slight odor of warm lubrication oil.
Overhead and between various machines one long strand of straw
material hummed around spinning pulleys and guides on the way to being cut in
lengths and pushed into boxes. Suddenly out of this mechanical array, a man
emerged. My recollection says he was short, perhaps even a little person, grimy
and oily from head to toe as he tended the machines and their supposed clean path to market. I noticed his
hands with oil pressed into every available crevice, dirty back and front. I also recall greasy hair and a large nose,
its pores also black with oil. He shook his fist at me indicating I should get
out and close the door. I stood there shocked for a moment then quickly backed
away and shut the door behind me.
By then my mother had completed her purchase and we left the
store. But, I never could erase the image of that factory floor from my mind. Since that time I have
never been able to see a straw without seeing the filthy conditions and the
filthy man responsible for its manufacture. Open and use one? Never. Won't do it. When people ask why I don't use straws I just
say I saw the guy who makes them.
Today I learned for probably more than 60 years I have been
on the politically correct side of the straw debate. Who knew there was a
debate about straws? I should have. What I saw today was notice of a movement by an organization called the Ocean Conservancy to encourage people to stop using straws because they end up in the ocean killing
wildlife, another senseless use of plastic with its enduring qualities. According to the conservancy, Americans eat out an average of four times a week and most of those meals involve at least one straw. If 25,000 people stop taking the straw, it will save 5 million straws over the course of a year, many of which could end up in the ocean.
Fine by
me. I can now take sanctimonious pride in supporting yet another noble effort
to save the oceans and their wildlife. As a matter of fact, because I haven't
used a straw since the early 1950s,
maybe I can be held up as a hero to the cause. Probably not considering I did it without even being aware of it as an issue, an
accidental environmentalist, at least in this context.
SKIP THE STRAW – The last straw challenge. Sign the pledge.
From Facebook
Pam Longobardi on the Ocean People Facebook page: there is NO challenge to keeping a stainless steel food grade straw clean, or tempered glass: see http://greenapplesupply.org/.../ppc-go-plastic-free-basic... and http://simplystraws.com/.....plastic is a toxic disposable nightmare from human lips to bird and turtle beaks
Carrie Ann
Nash Lots of special needs people need straws, but there
is a good alternative: my mom found safe acrylic, permanent straws that work
well most of the time. (A bit challenging to keep clean...)
Pam Longobardi on the Ocean People Facebook page: there is NO challenge to keeping a stainless steel food grade straw clean, or tempered glass: see http://greenapplesupply.org/.../ppc-go-plastic-free-basic... and http://simplystraws.com/.....plastic is a toxic disposable nightmare from human lips to bird and turtle beaks
greenapplesupply.org
Carrie Ann
Nash What she doesn't know is that many people with
various issues simply CANNOT SUCK from a non-malleable straw. It is easy to be
self righteous about this but your suggestions simply do not work for everyone.
And depending on how far this is taken - should people stop using the plastic
canulas such as the ones that keep my son alive and for which there is
currently no alternative?!
Nikki Caputo i
don't know that it's a self righteous issue as much as just gaps in
information...it takes a village...this is how we learn and grow.
bottom
line: it's about LOVE
Tim Jones
I think there can be a meeting of the minds here. Just like my not using straws
didn't make any difference at all in the amount dumped in the ocean, I should
think the people who need malleable straws should certainly have them as they
are a relatively small number compared with the general population and can be disposed of properly. It seems if
the rest of us gave up the straws, that is what would make the difference.
Nikki Caputo and
with knowledge that malleable straws (etc.) are important tools for some
people/situations, perhaps alternatives to what we are familiar with and/or to
what is currently available may be shared/innovated/imagined
Carrie Ann Nash I
appreciate the discussion. I'm sorry to Pam for name-calling. The toxicity and
omnipresence of plastic is horrifying, but it is equally difficult to contemplate
the medical world without plastic.
Pam Longobardi
everything is about information, balance, thoughtfulness,responsibility and
LOVE~ Carrie, apology accepted and thank you Carrie, Tim and Nikki for sharing
the concern to come up with creative and beautiful answers to this most
difficult of challenges. Its complicated and never have humans, nor the whole
interconnected planet we call home- EVER faced a more difficult and complex
time. Will we figure this out in time? All these discussions, large and small,
are the evolution of humanity.